Writing Advice from #1 Son

I have son who is an excellent writer. He would be great for advice and feedback – if only we were on the same page. We don’t read the same thing (although he did introduce me to the Night Angel trilogy which I loved) and we certainly don’t write about the same things.

Recently I was working on a new idea and passed over the first 200 words or so for his opinion. He threw it back at me. “I’m not reading anything where a little kid gets killed in the first sentence.” Fair enough. That might have been a bit violent and he is right in my target reader age group, so I figured it was a valid criticism. I made a change.

Back it came again. “I’m not reading it if you have to kill people. You are not allowed to kill anyone.” “Surely I can kill someone?” I ask hopefully. “Only very, very old people. And only if they are sick and about to die.” Hmmm. Not much room to work there but I rose to the challenge. I made a change. Back it came faster than before. “A cat, Mum. That’s just sick. I am not reading this.”

*sigh* I’ve put that ms away for a while.

BTW The Night Angel trilogy is very dark, very violent and very scary. Brent Weeks is apparently allowed to kill as many people as he likes! Not fair.

Subscribe to my newsletter


5 responses to “Writing Advice from #1 Son”

  1. Joanne Sandhu says:

    Loved this post. I have the same problem. After many re-writes of a first chapter, Mr 12 hissed through clenched teeth: I’m not reading this again until you’ve made all the changes you’re going to make! That was two years ago and I haven’t been brave enough to try again.

  2. katswhiskers says:

    You horrid mother, Sandy. I can’t believe you would subject your child to that!!! :O

    Kidding. Sounds like double standards there. NOT that I have tried to kill off any of my characters…

    I agree, btw. Our kids make great critters. Perhaps because they’ve grown up with that role? I wouldn’t submit a book without hearing my boys’ feedback – and making subsequent changes… or engaging in torrid debate!

  3. Just had my first laugh out loud moment of a very tiring day – thank you, Cat-loving Son!

  4. Katrina says:

    I think I’m with your son! Thanks for the giggle.

  5. DC Green says:

    My daughter urges me to kill more! But yes, double-standarded or not, our grommets are priceless (and brutally honest) critters!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *